Skip to content

An auditor’s look at Monday’s $210,000 decisions

Numbers first, vote second. Curtis Major looks at $210,000 in recent county decisions through an auditor’s lens, using the county’s own financial records.

An auditor’s look at Monday’s $210,000 decisions
Published:

In my day job as an internal audit manager, I test whether decisions are backed by evidence. I check whether the numbers existed before the money moved, whether money moved for a stated reason, and whether the right fund paid for the right thing.

This isn’t an audit. It’s how an auditor reads the public record of the Bourbon County Commission’s Nov. 9 meeting, along with county financial records obtained through an open records request.

At that meeting, two decisions involved $210,529.61 in public money. In both, commissioners voted before the figures that should inform the vote were on the table.

Commissioners voted 4-1 to move the sheriff’s office’s $90,139.25 computer and server purchase onto the jail sales tax fund, with Commissioner Mika Milburn-Kee opposed. They voted 3-2 to spend all $120,390.36 from the sale of the county building on West Second Street on a one-time employee bonus, with Milburn-Kee and Commissioner Samuel Tran opposed.

Neither purpose is the problem. Deputies need computers that meet the Kansas Bureau of Investigation’s Jan. 1 requirement, and employees deserve recognition.

My concern is the order of operations. Taxpayers are best served when the numbers come first and the vote comes second.

Concern 1: A cost moved to a restricted fund after it was paid

The sheriff, as an elected official, can spend within his own budget without the commission’s approval, and the computer purchase was made that way. The sheriff’s office told commissioners the cost fit within its budget, according to the county’s budget consultant, Baker Tilly.

What the office asked the commission for was something else: to move that already-paid cost onto the jail sales tax fund to keep a cushion for the rest of the year. Commissioners approved it 4-1.

To an auditor, that’s a reclassification after the fact. Those get close scrutiny, because charging a restricted fund for a cost already covered frees up operating money without saying what it’s for.

The county’s own records show how much room there already was. As of Nov. 13, the sheriff’s fund had collected $310,239 for housing other counties’ inmates, more than double the $128,066 budgeted, and its revenues for the year were running $170,502 ahead of its expenses.

That’s a turnaround from last fall, when commissioners discussed a potential $106,000 shortfall in the sheriff’s budget. Murphy told commissioners he had not asked Baker Tilly where the room in the budget came from, and the vote went ahead without that answer.

The 2026 budget also includes a $250,000 transfer into the sheriff’s fund, which had not been recorded as of Nov. 13.

No one said how the cushion would be used. Commissioners also disagreed over whether money left in the sheriff’s fund returns to the general fund at year’s end, and they voted without settling it.

The jail sales tax fund has obligations of its own. Voters approved the 0.4% tax in 2015 to fund a $6.8 million bond for the Bourbon County Law Enforcement Center, and that debt was refinanced in 2021.

According to the state treasurer’s amortization schedule, the county still owes $4.08 million in principal through 2035, with about $461,000 in payments due in 2027. The fund held about $1.79 million in cash as of Nov. 13, and this year it has also paid about $290,000 toward leases and a fleet agreement.

Computers may be an allowable use. But a use being allowed isn’t the same as it being the best one, and every dollar charged to the fund for a cost already covered is a dollar not held toward the debt still owed on the jail.

One loose end remains. When Chairman Gregg Motley asked whether anyone would check Stronghold’s billing for accounts moving to the sheriff’s new IT provider, no one volunteered.

Concern 2: One-time money committed without a calculation

Commissioner David Beerbower moved to give all the building sale proceeds to employees. There was no written proposal, no per-employee amount and no confirmed count of eligible staff.

The Government Finance Officers Association recommends that one-time money go to one-time expenses or to building reserves. A bonus passes the first part of that test, but known obligations should be covered first, and they weren’t checked.

Earlier this year, commissioners adopted a policy that pays out unused vacation at year’s end. Milburn-Kee said those payouts weren’t budgeted this year, and no one at the table knew what they will cost.

The math wasn’t run either. Motley estimated $1,100 per full-time employee and $550 per part-time employee. Using the commission’s own estimate of about 120 employees, roughly nine of them part-time, that totals about $127,000, nearly $7,000 more than the sale brought in.

Beerbower offered to have Baker Tilly calculate the exact figures by the next day. The commission voted instead on Motley’s estimate, with final amounts still to be calculated.

If the county’s 7.65% share of Social Security and Medicare comes out of the same pot, as Beerbower suggested, I estimate the real figure is closer to $970 per full-time employee. After the flat 22% federal withholding on bonuses and the employee’s own 7.65%, that’s about $680 before state taxes.

The bigger number on the horizon

Tonight, commissioners will hold a work session on 2027 health insurance. The renewal from Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas comes with an increase of about 15.71%.

The county now contributes $925 a month for each of 61 employees on employee-only coverage and about $1,700 a month for each of 17 on employee-plus coverage. That comes to roughly $1 million a year.

If those contributions rose by the same 15.71%, the county would pay about $160,000 more every year. That’s more than the building sale brought in once, and it doesn’t go away after one paycheck.

Employees took on higher premiums last year, as Beerbower himself noted. An employee on single coverage now pays about $130 a month. If that employee absorbed the full renewal increase, a one-time bonus of about $680 would be used up in roughly four months.

Holding premiums steady for 2027 could do more for those same employees than the bonus will. Commissioners committed the one-time money before they had seen what the recurring cost will be.

Recommendations

Both votes may turn out fine. But commissioners couldn’t know that when they cast them, and neither could the taxpayers they represent.

An auditor’s report ends with recommendations. These are simple:

  1. Don’t move costs into restricted funds after they’re paid unless there’s a stated purpose for the money it frees up.
  2. Require a written cost figure before any vote that commits money.
  3. Quantify known liabilities, such as vacation payouts and insurance increases, before spending one-time revenue.
  4. Check vendor billing whenever a department changes providers.

None of this requires saying no to deputies or employees. It requires commissioners to have the figures in hand before they vote, which is what taxpayers should be able to expect.

Curtis Major is the co-editor for The Bourbon County Monitor and an internal audit manager. The views expressed are his own and are separate from The Monitor’s news coverage.

Tags: Opinion

More in Opinion

See all

More from Curtis Major

See all